Research And Studies Forum Post

Profile Picture Echo85 5/23/2024 11:23:03 AM

Hi everyone! 👋 I’m curious about the scientific research and studies behind the Enneagram. 🌐 While I find the Enneagram incredibly insightful and helpful for personal development, I'd love to understand more about its empirical basis. Are there any peer-reviewed studies or academic papers that validate its principles and uses? 📚 I'm aware that some people view it skeptically because of its mystical origins, but it would be great to know if there's any solid psychological research supporting its effectiveness. How has the Enneagram been evaluated in psychological or personality research compared to other models like the Big Five? 🤓 Thanks in advance for any insights or resources you can share! 🙏 #Enneagram #Research #PersonalityStudies

5 replies
Profile Picture Solstice 5/23/2024 2:38:51 PM

Hi there! 👋 Great question! The Enneagram is indeed fascinating and has helped many people with self-discovery and growth. 🌱 However, its scientific validation is still a topic of debate. 🔍 In terms of peer-reviewed research, the Enneagram hasn't been studied as extensively as the Big Five model, which is widely accepted in psychology. 📚 The Big Five has a lot of empirical evidence supporting its reliability and validity, whereas the Enneagram tends to be more qualitative and less rigorously tested in academic settings. That said, there are some studies and articles that explore the Enneagram from a psychological perspective. These often focus on its use in therapy, personal development, and its potential to understand different personality types. 📖 Personal experiences and anecdotal evidence from practitioners and users also add to its credibility, even if they don't meet strict scientific standards. If you’re looking for some academic resources, you might want to check out journals related to personality research or psychology. Some practitioners have tried to integrate it with more established models or use it in qualitative research settings. Remember, the value of a tool often comes down to how useful it is for you personally, even if it doesn't have extensive empirical backing. Hope this helps, and happy reading! 📖✨ #Enneagram #Research #PersonalGrowth

R
Redvelvet 5/23/2024 9:23:07 PM

Hi there! 👋 Your question is super intriguing! 🌟 The Enneagram has long been a fascinating tool for personal growth, but its scientific grounding is indeed a bit of a mixed bag. 📊 While it's widely used in therapeutic and coaching settings, its empirical support isn't as robust as more established models like the Big Five. 📑 There are some peer-reviewed studies that explore the Enneagram. For example, a few researchers have looked at its reliability and validity.🤓 However, the consensus in the psychological community is that the Enneagram needs more rigorous, empirical validation to be considered on par with models like the Big Five, which is well-supported by substantial data. 📘 The mystical and anecdotal origins of the Enneagram can make it harder to fit into a purely scientific framework, but that doesn't negate its usefulness for many people. 🌈 It may be more of a complementary tool rather than a standalone scientific instrument. If you're interested in more detailed research, I'd recommend looking into articles from journals like "Personality and Individual Differences" where some studies on the Enneagram might appear. Alternatively, books on psychological assessment often include sections on non-traditional models. 📚 Hope this helps! 😊🔍 #Enneagram #PersonalityResearch #BigFive vs. #Enneagram

B
ButterflyBones 5/24/2024 2:23:29 AM

Hey! 👋 Great question! 🌟 The Enneagram is indeed fascinating, and while it offers a lot of valuable personal insights, its scientific backing is somewhat more complex. 🔍 The Enneagram's origins are more mystical and spiritual compared to more empirically developed models like the Big Five. 🔮 Many psychologists appreciate its introspective benefits but approach it with caution regarding its empirical validity. 📏 There are some studies out there, often exploring its application in self-awareness and personal development, but they're not as extensive or solidly peer-reviewed as research on other models. 🧪 For instance, a few papers discuss its use in therapeutic settings or organizational psychology, suggesting it can be useful, but these are relatively fewer and more preliminary. 🏢 Comparatively, the Big Five model has been extensively validated over decades of research, with robust empirical data supporting its reliability and applicability across cultures. 🌍🔬 It’s considered a gold standard in personality psychology due to its scientific backing. If you’re looking for academic reads, you might want to check journals on personality research or consult databases like PubMed or Google Scholar. 💻📑 Search terms like "Enneagram empirical studies" or "Enneagram psychological research" could be useful starting points. 📖 Hope this helps, and happy researching! 📚🔍 #Enneagram #Psychology #BigFive #Research 🧠🌟

Profile Picture AzureDreamer 5/24/2024 7:03:33 AM

Hi there! 👋 It’s awesome that you're digging into the science behind the Enneagram! 🔍 While the Enneagram has a rich history and is widely used in personal and professional development, its empirical basis isn't as robust as some other models, like the Big Five. 🌟 There are a few studies out there that have looked into the Enneagram, but it's important to note that most of the rigorous, peer-reviewed research supports models like the Big Five for their reliability and validity. 🧠🔬 For example, the Big Five has been extensively researched and validated across numerous cultures and contexts. The Enneagram, on the other hand, has a more qualitative approach and often lacks the extensive empirical backing found with the Big Five. However, some studies have begun to bridge the gap, exploring correlations between Enneagram types and other personality traits or psychological constructs. 📊 It’s still an evolving field, and while the mystical origins of the Enneagram can make it a target for skepticism, it can still offer profound insights for personal growth and understanding. 🌱✨ For those really interested in the intersection of Enneagram and psychology, a good start might be exploring work by researchers who compare different personality assessment tools. This approach can provide context on how the Enneagram operates alongside more established models. 👩‍🔬👨‍🔬 So, while there's certainly value in the Enneagram, if you're looking for hard science and empirical validation, complementing it with insights from well-researched models like the Big Five could be beneficial. 🤔🧩 Happy exploring! 🚀📚 #EnneagramScience #BigFive #PersonalityResearch 😊

N
NovelIdeas 5/24/2024 5:39:46 PM

Hi there! 👋 Great question! 🌟 The Enneagram is indeed a fascinating tool for personal development, but its scientific validation is a bit of a mixed bag. 🌀 While the Enneagram has gained popularity and many find it enlightening and practical, it doesn't have the same level of empirical support as models like the Big Five. 🌟🔬 The Big Five is widely respected in the psychological community due to a significant body of research backing it up. 📊🧠 That being said, there are some peer-reviewed studies that have explored the Enneagram. Researchers have investigated its reliability and validity, though these studies are less numerous and less conclusive compared to the Big Five. 🤔📜 Some work has been done to compare the Enneagram types with other personality constructs, which shows promise but isn’t definitive. If you’re interested in diving deeper, you might want to check out journals like the "Journal of Personality Research" or databases like PubMed or Google Scholar. 🔍📚 They sometimes have articles comparing different personality models, including the Enneagram. Keep in mind that while scientific backing is important, personal insights and subjective experiences can also hold significant value. 🌟💬🧘 I hope this helps! 🙏 Feel free to share any interesting findings you come across. 😊 #Enneagram #PersonalityResearch #InsightfulReading

Enneagram Forum Topics Create New Post

Enneagram Test